So here’s the wrap up, I’ve spent over a week with each of these three free web services and I have to say overall, they are all amazing. They are all easy enough for a novice to figure out, and allow a huge range of easy choices for making updates and adding content over time. But each one has it’s advantages, and best uses.
WordPress is the best option if you are a non-programmer and plan to do it all yourself. It’s rock solid, and in many ways very easy to figure out. I’ve seen programmers who are familiar with WordPress churn out amazingly customized websites with the huge amount of widgets available but for the average person, it’s hard, and costly to customize the way you can with the other two options.
Weebly is in a class by itself in many ways since it allows you to build a true website, and not just a blog, but it’s drag a drop interface can be confusing and frustrating for some. It however offers a lot of customization options if you are a programmer or going to use one to customize your site.
Tumblr offers a good mix with extreme ease of use for novices along with easy customization options for programmers or designers looking at it for the first time. Tumblr’s balance between these two important aspects are what make me recommend it as the best solution in most instances. If you want a more complete site, go with Weebly, and if you want to do it all yourself as a novice WordPress might be a good choice, but Tumblr is easier to use that WordPress in my opinion and while not doing everything that Weebly does, gets close.

21 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 6, 2010 at 8:52 pm
Daniel Doherty
Thank very much for taking the time to give such a thorough breakdown, I (& am sure others will too) found it really useful and it answered a lot of questions I had!
If you sign up for the Weeby Pro (You can take weebly footer off the bottom of the free version site and also have up to 10 websites) can also embed video’s straight into weebly now. More benefits are here
http://support.weebly.com/support/index.php?pg=kb.page&id=28
If you decide to go pro here’s my affiliate link http://affiliate.weebly.com/scripts/click.php?aid=4bd2610254480&cid=d4aceefd I’d just spend the credit back on Weebly I like them so much : )
Although dropping the youtube url in the weebyly youtube player is very easy and available on the FREE 2 websites you can build!!
You can also take any html widget or google gadget and cut and paste it onto the HTML code widget & it works : )
Now just need a good designer to sharpen up my sites : )
Starting to show my Weebly love here & also here
http://affiliate.weebly.com/scripts/click.php?aid=4bd2610254480&cid=d4aceefd
May 7, 2010 at 7:33 pm
amescreative
Great points, thanks Daniel. I’ve designed websites for years and would be happy to help you sharpen up your sites. You can see some of my work at http://www.amescreative.com I was very impressed with Weebly as a total website solution. It’s certainly more than just blog software, and for people who want the extra features it’s worth a little extra learning.
September 17, 2010 at 12:23 am
Laura Novak
I just found your tutorials! Thank you! I am beginning to explore how to set up my author website and am quite confused. Never even heard of Weebly still another author I met on Twitter recommended it.
Question is: I am having a designer make the cover of my ebook now. Can I “lay in” the book cover/artwork to any of these sites after I’ve set one up. In other words, change the artwork later? Many thanks for your work!
February 4, 2011 at 5:28 am
amescreative
Hi Laura,
The answer is YES, you can put your ebook cover on any of these sites, and later change it without any hassle.
Cheers,
Jonathan
January 10, 2011 at 10:26 pm
Bebas
Just finished watching your five-part review and wanted to say: the screencasts were really good! I blog on WordPress.com, also have a tumblelog and wanted to see what’s out there. The videos are definitely helpful for newbies, too, they’re clear and you’re easy to listen to. Thanks!
January 11, 2011 at 2:02 pm
Daniel Doherty
I am still using weebly and the new features they keep announcing just seem to tick off my wish list
Can now put different header on each page, plus image perfect software helps manipulate better images. Am still learning but the drag and drop nature of weebly just seems to resonate well with the way I think : )
Also added lot’s of new templates and the pro version means you can use a HTML5 video player so video works on Ipads?apple stuff too : )
Silly question but would you have just the weebly video bits from all 5 video’s on just one video? Would love to add that as a help video to here http://geolocation.weebly.com/comparisons.html a site of weebly love! Although i still have to go and apply new lesson to it yet.
Pleased with my landing page http://www.HappinessEvangelist.com but like everything is still a work in progress…..
Thanks again for your hard work and still refer people to them.
Happy 2011 Daniel
January 14, 2011 at 2:51 pm
Don’t Forget About Weebly | Telablue, Inc.
[...] Amescreative says, “Weebly is in a class by itself in many ways since it allows you to build a true website, and not just a blog, but it’s drag and drop interface can be confusing and frustrating for some. It however offers a lot of customization options if you are a programmer or going to use one to customize your site,” and goes on to compare with Tumblr, which was mentioned by Webories, “Tumblr offers a good mix with extreme ease of use for novices along with easy customization options for programmers or designers looking at it for the first time. Tumblr’s balance between these two important aspects are what make me recommend it as the best solution in most instances. If you want a more complete site, go with Weebly, and if you want to do it all yourself as a novice WordPress might be a good choice, but Tumblr is easier to use that WordPress in my opinion and while not doing everything that Weebly does, gets close.” Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year 2010Telablue Reviews “6 Website Fixes to Make Now” [...]
March 2, 2011 at 7:36 pm
Annabelle
Thanks for taking the time to review… I am not a programmer but want the ability to have a programmer fix up my mess should I need it. I am still weighing b/t Weebly and Tumblr with a slight lean towards Weebly. I will keep your info at hand should I need to clean up any mess I make!
March 7, 2011 at 5:03 pm
amescreative
Hi Annabelle,
Weebly has made HUGE strides in the past year since my video. It now allows changes to the source code even more easily than Tumblr. I still think Tumblr is the best choice if you want to Blog. But if you want to build websites, especially for business, Weebly is the best choice now. And in your position, it’s easy to have a programmer get into Weebly and clean up any mess or add custom stuff to your pages.
Cheers,
Jonathan
March 19, 2011 at 6:25 pm
Eydie
Hi all. I do have to disagree with you a bit. You CAN design an entire website using the WordPress Platform. My website is 100% WordPress….as are many others.
If you are an individual who is looking to blog for fun and pleasure, I’m sure Weebly and Tumblr are sufficient…. However, if you have a business, then WordPress offers a more powerful platform.
Ease of use doesn’t always cut it when it comes to profitability. I think people should be aware and understand all the limitations of each platform and not just from the ease of use standpoint. Just because something is easy to use doesn’t mean its the best choice.
From a client of mine, who loves Weebly and is having a difficult time weaning herself from it, she mentioned to me that she can’t set up a shopping cart on Weebly. Well, that doesn’t translate into profitability in my book. Please correct me if I’m wrong as far as the shopping cart is concerned.
So, I would caution users – remember that these video tips are for ‘ease of use’ and not necessarily for SEO which is why business owners and entrepreneurs use WordPress – or even TypePad.
Otherwise, I did enjoy the quality of your videos.
Eydie
March 21, 2011 at 2:54 am
amescreative
Thanks for the comment Eydie! True, there must be a balance between ease of use and functionality. WordPress seems to offer a far greater number of plugins and modifications. These are inaccessible to the ordinary non-technical business owner though. They are fairly simple if you are familiar with them, but just complex enough to intimidate those who I’d suggest use Weebly. Weebly actually did implement a shopping cart that is very easy to use, and they have SEO options that are about as good as Joomla or other more complex CMS. If you have a programmer, or are html-saavy then you can certainly do more with WordPress, but if you are not, or don’t want to pay a programmer to help then I still feel Weebly is a better choice. 75% of small business owners I work with don’t do e-commerce anyways. They simply want a better way to get more customers contacting them. This has been my experience at least.
March 25, 2011 at 4:19 pm
jdavet
Just wanted to thank you for the reviews of the three free blog sites. I was planning on making my wife a website to promote her Zumba classes, and, because of your videos and comments, I decided to go with Weebly. Thanks again for all of your incite and help!
March 26, 2011 at 5:15 am
amescreative
You’re welcome Jdavet. You’ll find Weebly is about the easiest way to make a full website that’s out there right now. Weebly has recently added simple e-commerce for their pro version, along with forums, and a very simple, very powerful javascript picture gallery that looks great! Post a link to your website here when you’re done! Cheers!
April 6, 2011 at 6:32 pm
Jake
Good comparisons. I am a Weebly pro guy myself, for about a year now. I think it is excellent value, and you are right that they have added a ton of improvements and features over the last year.
April 21, 2011 at 11:19 pm
someone :)
I liked a lot the comparison, helped me a lot!
But here’s a question:
If I delete my weebly, can i make one with the same e-mail address?
If not… is there a way to reactivate it somehow?
May 3, 2011 at 3:54 pm
amescreative
I’ve never deleted a Weebly account so I don’t have the answer for that one. You can make multiple websites under the same account, and turn websites off or on so I’ve never had the need to delete a Weebly account. Anyone else know the answer to this?
August 10, 2011 at 7:11 pm
Jeremy Kinney
When I first started designing my website I tried WordPress first but got frustrated regularly. After trying Weebly and watching the tutorials available on weebly.com, my website started taking off immediately! It’s very easy to use and has been a total saver. I have did everything myself (with no web design experience) and I’m sure it could be much better (as it will in the future) with the help of someone technically inclined. If you’re curious about the capabilities of weebly, check out my site at http://www.theawarenessrevolution.com At least this way you will see what weebly can do and figure out if it’s right for you. Good luck in your endeavor!
August 19, 2011 at 4:39 am
jessie
hey, jeremy, just checked out your site, good job!..
btw, how did u create the links in the footer section?
i have been working on that for hours..lol
November 2, 2011 at 12:27 pm
Josh
Hi, great review! Very helpful. Did you come across LightCMS and if so was there a reason you did not consider reviewing it alongside Weebly and Tumblr?
Thanks!
November 2, 2011 at 3:28 pm
amescreative
Hi Josh, Yes I looked at LightCMS and the main reason I didn’t review it alongside Weebly and Tumblr was that it required installation on a server which is more complex than many people want in a simple CMS. There are a LOT of products like LightCMS that are installable but the nature of Weebly, Tumblr, and WordPress is that you can start using them without getting a web host, and without having to install and maintain them. That’s a big point for a lot of people.
November 2, 2011 at 3:50 pm
Josh
Hi, I dont think you looked at LightCMS http://www.lightcms.com – maybe another site or product?
I used LightCMS this year for a free 3 page website and it seemed very like Weebly and Tumblr, if not slightly better. And free! It was a doddle to set up and I used CNAME to point the domain name.